光学学报, 2024, 44 (6): 0601007, 网络出版: 2024-03-19  

SO2紫外相机标准泡定标法的误差校正

Error Correction for Cell Calibration of SO2 Ultraviolet Camera
作者单位
1 烟台大学物理与电子信息学院,山东 烟台 264005
2 中国科学院精密测量科学与技术创新研究院,湖北 武汉 430071
3 中国科学院西安光学精密机械研究所中国科学院光谱成像技术重点实验室,陕西 西安 710119
4 中国科学院国家空间科学中心,北京 100190
摘要
针对标准泡法在远距离SO2监测定标不准确的实际问题,开展定标误差校正方法研究。首先,基于标准泡定标法原理以及大气辐射传输理论,提出消除光稀释效应影响的图像校正方法;然后,在充分分析窗片与滤光片反射以及气溶胶散射效应的基础上,对反射效应及散射特性对定标结果的影响进行量化;最后,综合上述影响因素计算得到光稀释效应校正及散射特性修正的定标曲线,并比较误差校正的标准泡定标法与DOAS定标法在反演SO2柱密度图像以及SO2排放速率之间差异。结果表明,所提出的校正方法可将标准泡法与DOAS法的定标结果差异从59%降低至7%,验证了该误差校正方法的有效性和准确度。
Abstract
Objective

Industrial chimneys, ship exhaust, and volcanic eruption processes can emit large amounts of harmful SO2 into the atmosphere, causing serious pollution to the environment. The development of effective SO2 monitoring tools can provide a strong guarantee for atmospheric environmental management. In recent years, SO2 ultraviolet (UV) cameras have been rapidly developed and widely applied by virtue of their high spatio-temporal resolution, high detection sensitivity, and two-dimensional detection imaging capability. Due to the limitation of physical principles, the initial amount measured by the SO2 UV camera is the optical thickness of SO2 gas, which needs to be retrieved into a concentration image with the help of calibration curves, and the accuracy of calibration curves directly affects the accuracy of SO2 concentration results. Cell calibration and differential optical absorption spectroscopy (DOAS) calibration are two main methods for obtaining calibration curves. In terms of equipment cost, easy operation, and system stability, the cell method is significantly better than the DOAS method, but its calibration accuracy is seriously affected by the light dilution effect, reflections on the windows of the calibration cell and filter, and aerosol scattering factors. Additionally, with the rising detection distance, the above factors, especially the influence of the light dilution effect, become increasingly more serious. To improve the calibration accuracy of the cell method, we research the calibration error correction method to address the practical problem of inaccurate cell method calibration in remote SO2 monitoring.

Methods

In practice, since the factors affecting the accuracy of the cell method are mainly from the light dilution effect, window reflection, and the scattering of aerosols, it is necessary to correct each of these factors. The specific method is as follows. Firstly, the image correction method (ICM) is proposed for correcting the light dilution effect, and the extinction coefficient is obtained by fitting the intensity information of the measurement points at different distances in the UV camera images. Additionally, the optical thickness image of the cell at the measured distance is calculated by the extinction coefficient, and then the calibration curve with the correction of the light dilution effect is obtained. Then, based on the analysis of window reflection and aerosol scattering effect, the influence of the reflection effect and scattering characteristics on the calibration results are quantified. Finally, the calibration curves with the correction of light dilution effect and scattering characteristics are calculated by combining the above influencing factors.

Results and Discussions

Based on the Etna volcanic plume image data captured by Professor Jonas Gli? from the Norwegian Air Research Institute using a SO2 ultraviolet camera, the Etna volcanic plume SO2 concentration image is retrieved by calibration curves before and after the correction of the light dilution effect. The results are compared with the retrieval results of the DOAS calibration curve, and the results show that the correction of the light dilution effect can reduce the differences between the cell method and the DOAS method from 59.0% to 31.3%, which verifies the effectiveness of ICM in correcting light dilution effect. After correction for reflection and scattering effects, the difference between the cell method and the DOAS method is reduced to 7%. The cell method and DOAS method show good agreement in the time domain after correction, and the fitting curve slope of the primary function of the calibration results is 0.924, with a goodness-of-fit of 0.998.

Conclusions

The results show that the proposed error correction method for cell calibration of the SO2 UV camera can improve the calibration curve accuracy. The fitting accuracy of the extinction coefficient and the measurement accuracy of the filter reflectance and the quartz window directly affect the accuracy of the calibration curve. The error analysis results show that a 10% shift in the extinction coefficients εA and εB obtained from channels A and B fitting will cause an error of 8.44% and 13.57% for SO2 column density retrieval respectively, while a 10% shift in background light intensity will result in an error of 4.98% for SO2 column density retrieval. Additionally, a 10% error in the filter reflectance and the quartz window will result in a 6.26% and 1.95% shift in the SO2 column density respectively. Increasing the interval distance of sampling points and the number of sampling points can improve the fitting accuracy of the extinction coefficient. The high-resolution UV spectrometer ensures that the filter reflectance and the quartz window are accurately measured to control errors caused by the reflectance uncertainty. The proposed error correction method for calibration curves solves the limitation that the cell method cannot be applied to monitor the plumes at long distances and high carbon black concentrations, which is important for better applications of SO2 UV cameras in volcanoes, ships, and industrial chimneys.

张会亮, 李发泉, 李娟, 王后茂, 张子豪, 郭建军, 武魁军, 何微微. SO2紫外相机标准泡定标法的误差校正[J]. 光学学报, 2024, 44(6): 0601007. Huiliang Zhang, Faquan Li, Juan Li, Houmao Wang, Zihao Zhang, Jianjun Guo, Kuijun Wu, Weiwei He. Error Correction for Cell Calibration of SO2 Ultraviolet Camera[J]. Acta Optica Sinica, 2024, 44(6): 0601007.

引用该论文: TXT   |   EndNote

相关论文

加载中...

关于本站 Cookie 的使用提示

中国光学期刊网使用基于 cookie 的技术来更好地为您提供各项服务,点击此处了解我们的隐私策略。 如您需继续使用本网站,请您授权我们使用本地 cookie 来保存部分信息。
全站搜索
您最值得信赖的光电行业旗舰网络服务平台!