太阳模拟器用自由曲面聚光镜设计 下载: 602次
The solar simulator is a device that simulates solar irradiation characteristics indoors. In the design of the solar simulator, the irradiation uniformity is an important indicator, which directly determines the accuracy of the device. Hence, improving irradiation uniformity has become a key research direction. In a solar simulator, the concentrator system is one of the key components, which typically uses an ellipsoidal condenser. By the ellipsoidal condenser, the radiation flux from the light source placed on the first focal plane will be focused on the second focal plane. As a result, a convergent spot is formed on the incident surface of the optical integrator, which is dense at the center, sparse at the edge, and Gaussian in shape. This uneven illuminance distribution is detrimental to the irradiation uniformity of the entire system. To address the poor performance of the solar simulator due to the low irradiation uniformity of the optical integrator's incident surface, this paper proposes and designs a free-form surface condenser as the concentrator system of the solar simulator. On the premise that the focusing efficiency is ensured, the irradiation uniformity on the second focal plane is effectively improved as the irradiation uniformity of the solar simulator is improved through better irradiation distribution on the optical integrator's incident surface.
In this paper, the free-form surface condenser used in the solar simulation system is studied. First, the mapping relationship between the outgoing angle of the light source and the corresponding point on the target surface is determined. According to Fresnel's law and the mapping relationship, the differential equation is derived, which is solved by the Runge-Kutta method to calculate the discrete point data. After curve fitting of the discrete point data, the bus line of the free-form surface condenser is obtained. Second, the generatrix of the free-form surface is generated by the Bézier curve. A simulated annealing algorithm is employed to conduct feedback-oriented optimization on the free-form surface condenser with an extended light source. Third, the optical system of the solar simulator is modeled by the software LightTools, and the ellipsoidal condenser and the free-form surface condenser are configured in the same optical system of a solar simulator for comparative analysis. Fourth, the irradiance and the irradiation nonuniformity within ?100 mm of the irradiation surface are taken as the evaluation indexes, and error simulation analyses are performed to investigate the influence of surface accuracy, axial position offset, vertical-axis position offset, and angle offset of the free-form surface condenser on the irradiance and the irradiation nonuniformity.
In this paper, a free-form surface condenser is proposed and designed. The point light source model is used to construct a reasonable initial structure according to the law of conservation of energy, the edge light theory, and the mapping method. In the design proposal, the generatrix of the free-form surface condenser is represented by the Bézier curve. The parameters of the Bézier curve are selected as the optimization variables, and the irradiation uniformity on the target surface is selected as the evaluation function. In the meantime, a simulated annealing algorithm is used to optimize the free-form surface with an extended light source. The simulation results of LightTools show that the irradiation uniformity on the irradiation surface of the solar simulator is significantly improved when the free surface condenser is used. The irradiation nonuniformity within ?50 mm of the irradiation surface is better than 0.32%, and that within ?100 mm of the irradiation surface is better than 0.53%. When the surface and pose errors of the free-form surface condenser are taken into account according to the existing processing, assembly, and adjustment level, the irradiance greater than S0 is considered feasible on the irradiation surface, and the irradiation nonuniformity is less than 1.5%. This verifies the feasibility of the processing, detection, assembly, and adjustment of the free-form surface condenser.
1 引言
太阳模拟器是一种模拟太阳光辐照特性的设备[1],可应用在航天器的热平衡和热控涂层特性实验、太阳能电池检测、遥感技术中室内模拟太阳光谱辐照、建筑行业中材料性能老化测试等方面[2-4]。
辐照不均匀度是太阳模拟器设计的重要指标之一,直接决定太阳模拟器的精度。日本牛尾机电公司生产的USS-2000A太阳模拟器的辐照面直径为100 mm,辐照不均匀度为
聚光系统是太阳模拟器的关键系统之一,通常采用椭球聚光镜。它将放置在第一焦点附近的光源发出的辐射通量会聚到其第二焦面上,即在积分器入射端面形成一定范围的辐照分布,该辐照分布先被积分器场镜组对称分割,经过积分器投影镜组叠加成像后,再经准直系统,最终在辐照面上形成一个辐照均匀的光斑[7],而聚光镜第二焦面上的辐照均匀性直接影响整个太阳模拟器系统辐照面上的辐照均匀性。为了提高第二焦面的辐照均匀性,Wang等[8]采用抛物面反射镜结合菲涅耳透镜作为光学聚光器,但其聚光后的通量仍服从高斯分布。Li等[9]设计了一种三维复合抛物线聚光器(CPC),该聚光器虽然提高了聚光效率,但是第二焦面能量分布分散的情况并未得到改善。为此,任兰旭等[10]提出一种非共轴椭球聚光镜,该椭球聚光镜是在子午面内以第一焦点为中心,将椭圆曲线的长轴相对于光轴旋转一定角度,再绕原轴线旋转一周后形成的,可有效提高第二焦面的辐照均匀性,但加工过程过于复杂。吕涛等[11]从椭球面方程泰勒展开后得到的高阶方程中演变得到一个变形的椭球面,并通过几个变形系数控制面型,但该方法只能通过试凑确定系数数值,操作性较差。
本文设计了一种自由曲面聚光镜作为太阳模拟器的聚光系统,该系统在保证聚光效率的前提下,有效提高了第二焦面上的辐照均匀性,即改善了积分器入射面的辐照分布情况,最终显著提高了太阳模拟系统辐照面的辐照均匀性。所设计系统的辐照度不小于一个太阳常数S0(1353 W/m2),辐照面
2 自由曲面聚光镜的设计
2.1 自由曲面聚光镜的生成
针对传统椭球聚光镜第二焦面的能量分布中心高、边缘低,呈高斯分布的问题[13],以提高第二焦面上的辐照均匀性为目标,提出一种自由曲面聚光镜的设计方法。根据能量守恒定律、边光原理和映射法对自由曲面聚光镜进行设计,建立光源出射角度与自由曲面目标面对应点的映射关系,并依据菲涅耳定律结合映射关系推导出微分方程,通过龙格-库塔法求解微分方程,计算出自由曲面母线上的离散点[14]。
首先基于点光源模型,计算出光源选定发光区域出射光的光通量
式中:
选取短弧氙灯作为光源,短弧氙灯的配光曲线呈轴对称分布,发光角度为20°~125°,短弧氙灯的配光曲线如
式中:
如
图 2. 光源与目标面能量映射示意图
Fig. 2. Schematic of energy mapping between light source and target surface
根据能量守恒定律,假设光传递过程中没有能量损失,即光源发出的能量经过反射后全部传递到自由曲面的目标面内,可以认为
利用
图 3. 光源和自由曲面以及目标面分布示意图
Fig. 3. Distribution diagram of light source, free-form surface, and target surface
入射光线的单位矢量为
反射光线的单位矢量为
式中:
式中:
将
从而推导出
为了与后续光学系统匹配,以及满足系统光瞳衔接原理,取太阳模拟器系统常用相对孔径
式中:
以某气象用太阳模拟器聚光镜为例,将其第一焦点到第二焦点的工作距离
2.2 基于贝塞尔曲线多参数优化自由曲面聚光镜的方法
由于氙灯是具有一定面积的扩展光源,在针对点光源设计的自由曲面聚光镜中引入扩展光源后,自由曲面目标面的辐照均匀性大幅降低,因此需要对设计结果进行反馈优化。利用菲涅耳定律计算出自由曲面聚光镜轮廓线的离散点坐标,将得到的离散点拟合成贝塞尔曲线,并反算出控制该段曲线轮廓的贝塞尔曲线控制点坐标以及所对应的切线长度和切向角。可通过改变控制点坐标以及所对应的切线长度和切向角来改变曲线的轮廓,实现对光线反射角度的调整。贝塞尔曲线的函数表达式[19]为
式中:
将整个曲线轮廓细分,分别选取每段细分曲线轮廓的优化变量、评价函数和优化算法,以提高自由曲面聚光镜目标面的辐照均匀性。
以细分曲线轮廓的第一段为例,P0至P3所表示的细分曲线轮廓可以由P1、P2控制点的坐标以及所对应的切线长度和切向角表示。当控制点坐标由P1和P2变化到P11和P21时,细分曲线轮廓发生了变化,故选取P1、P2的坐标和所对应的切线长度和切向角作为优化变量,对细分曲线轮廓进行优化,结果如
图 4. 利用贝塞尔曲线构建自由曲面聚光镜轮廓线示意图
Fig. 4. Sketch map of contour line of free-form surface condenser constructed by Bézier curve
将仿真后的自由曲面聚光镜目标面的辐照均匀度作为评价函数,对目标面进行网格划分,将目标面上的辐照度进行归一化处理,得到
式中:
采用模拟退火算法[20-21]对贝塞尔曲线进行优化,设置退火的初始温度为
式中:
优化过程中选取的温度更新参数为0.85[22],则温度的变化可表示为
在算法优化过程中,
式中:
在整个优化过程中,当温度变化到
图 5. 自由曲面聚光镜的三维离散点云模型。(a)优化前的模型;(b)优化后的模型
Fig. 5. 3D discrete point cloud models of free-form surface condenser. (a) Model before optimization; (b) optimized model
图 6. 初始结构和优化结构轮廓线对比
Fig. 6. Comparison of contour lines between initial structure and optimized structure
图 7. 自由曲面聚光镜的目标面辐照度分布。(a)优化前的辐照度分布;(b)优化后的辐照度分布
Fig. 7. Irradiance distribution of target surface of free-form surface condenser. (a) Irradiance distribution before optimization; (b) optimized irradiance distribution
由
3 仿真分析
利用LightTools软件对太阳模拟器光学系统进行建模,将椭球聚光镜和自由曲面聚光镜置于同一太阳模拟器光学系统中进行仿真,使用蒙特卡罗方法对2000万条光线进行追迹,并对设计参量进行仿真调试,太阳模拟器光学系统仿真图如
图 9. 使用椭球聚光镜的太阳模拟器辐照面的辐照度分布
Fig. 9. Irradiance distribution of solar simulator on irradiation surface using ellipsoidal condenser
表 1. 使用椭球聚光镜和自由曲面聚光镜的太阳模拟器辐照不均匀度比较
Table 1. Comparison of irradiation nonuniformity of solar simulator using ellipsoidal condenser and free-form surface condenser
|
图 10. 使用自由曲面聚光镜的太阳模拟器辐照面的辐照度分布
Fig. 10. Irradiance distribution of solar simulator on irradiation surface using free-form surface condenser
从
式中:
图 11. 椭球聚光镜和自由曲面聚光镜的辐照不均匀度对比
Fig. 11. Comparison of irradiation nonuniformity between ellipsoidal condenser and free-form surface condenser
对比
为了评价使用自由曲面聚光镜的太阳模拟器加工装调的可行性,仿真分析了自由曲面聚光镜加工装调过程中可能产生的误差对太阳模拟器光学性能的影响[25]。以辐照面
图 12. 自由曲面聚光镜的面形精度对辐照度和辐照不均匀度的影响。(a)辐照度;(b)辐照不均匀度
Fig. 12. Influence of surface accuracy of free-form surface condenser on irradiance and irradiation nonuniformity. (a) Irradiance; (b) irradiation nonuniformity
图 13. 自由曲面聚光镜的沿轴位置偏移对辐照度和辐照不均匀度的影响。(a)辐照度;(b)辐照不均匀度
Fig. 13. Influence of the axial position offset of the free-form surface condenser on irradiance and irradiation nonuniformity. (a) Irradiance; (b) irradiation nonuniformity
图 14. 自由曲面聚光镜的垂轴位置偏移对辐照度和辐照不均匀度的影响。(a)辐照度;(b)辐照不均匀度
Fig. 14. Influence of vertical axis position offset of free-form surface condenser on irradiance and irradiation nonuniformity. (a) Irradiance; (b) irradiation nonuniformity
图 15. 自由曲面聚光镜的角度偏移对辐照度和辐照不均匀度的影响。(a)辐照度;(b)辐照不均匀度
Fig. 15. Influence of angle offset of free-form surface condenser on irradiation and irradiation nonuniformity.
由图
4 结论
设计了一种自由曲面聚光镜,基于点光源模型依据能量守恒定律和边光理论以及映射法建立良好的初始结构,采用贝塞尔曲线表征自由曲面聚光镜母线,选取贝塞尔曲线的参数作为优化变量以及目标面上的辐照均匀度作为评价函数,使用模拟退火算法对引入扩展光源的自由曲面进行反馈优化。仿真结果表明:采用自由曲面聚光镜后,太阳模拟器辐照面的辐照均匀性显著提高,
[1] 刘石, 张国玉, 孙高飞, 等. 高精度准直式太阳模拟器光机结构设计[J]. 红外与激光工程, 2015, 44(4): 1229-1235.
[2] 苏拾, 张国玉, 付芸, 等. 太阳模拟器的新发展[J]. 激光与光电子学进展, 2012, 49(7): 070003.
[3] 杨林华, 李竑松. 国外大型太阳模拟器研制技术概述[J]. 航天器环境工程, 2009, 26(2): 162-167.
Yang L H, Li H S. The development of large solar simulators in the world[J]. Spacecraft Environment Engineering, 2009, 26(2): 162-167.
[4] 孙超, 金志樑, 宋扬, 等. 多源分布式稳态太阳模拟器设计[J]. 光学学报, 2022, 42(10): 1022001.
[5] 宋培宇. 高准直高辐照度太阳模拟器的设计与仿真分析[D]. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学, 2017.
SongP Y. Design and simulation analysis of solar simulator with high collimation and high irradiance[D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2017.
[6] 刘石. 高精度准直式太阳模拟器及其关键技术研究[D]. 长春: 长春理工大学, 2014.
LiuS. Study on key technique of couimation solar simulator with high-precision[D]. Changchun: Changchun University of Science and Technology, 2014.
[7] 刘石, 张国玉, 孙高飞, 等. 具有一个太阳常量的高准直太阳模拟器光学系统设计[J]. 光子学报, 2014, 43(11): 1122005.
[8] Wang W, Aichmayer L, Laumert B, et al. Design and validation of a low-cost high-flux solar simulator using Fresnel lens concentrators[J]. Energy Procedia, 2014, 49: 2221-2230.
[9] Li L F, Wang B, Pottas J, et al. Design of a compound parabolic concentrator for a multi-source high-flux solar simulator[J]. Solar Energy, 2019, 183: 805-811.
[10] 任兰旭, 魏秀东, 牛文达, 等. 非共轴椭球面聚光阵列式高焦比太阳模拟器[J]. 光学学报, 2012, 32(10): 1022002.
[11] 吕涛, 张景旭, 付东辉, 等. 可提高太阳模拟器均匀性的变形椭球面聚光镜[J]. 光学学报, 2013, 33(12): 1223001.
[12] General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of the People's Republic of China, Standardization Administration of the People's Republic of China. Photovoltaic devices - Part 9: Solar simulator performance requirements:GB/T 6495.9—2006[S]. Beijing: China StandardsPress, 2006.
国家质量监督检验检疫总局, 国家标准化管理委员会. 光伏器件 第9部分:太阳模拟器性能要求:GB/T 6495.9—2006[S]. 北京: 中国标准出版社, 2006.
[13] 明杉炽, 孙高飞, 张国玉, 等. 太阳模拟器宽范围辐照连续可调节系统设计[J]. 光学学报, 2021, 41(16): 1622002.
[14] 马宇飞. 自由曲面照明设计及其优化方法的研究[D]. 杭州: 浙江工业大学, 2014.
MaY F. Research on the design method and optimization method of freeform illumination[D]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University of Technology, 2014.
[15] 陈家奇, 顾国超. 利用映射法构造自由曲面反射镜[J]. 长春理工大学学报(自然科学版), 2013, 36(6): 1-5.
Chen J Q, Gu G C. Using mapping-method to form freeform surface reflector[J]. Journal of Changchun University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition), 2013, 36(6): 1-5.
[16] 朱小芳, 李红波, 薛永胜, 等. 反射罩光学设计与均匀性仿真[J]. 光电技术应用, 2010, 25(6): 18-21.
[17] 高雁, 刘洪波, 王丽, 等. 大面积准直型太阳模拟器的设计与研制[J]. 中国光学, 2014, 7(4): 657-664.
[18] 易大义, 沈云宝, 李有法, 等. 计算方法[M]. 杭州: 浙江大学出版社, 2002: 240-248.
YiD Y, ShenY B, LiY F, et al. Calculation method[M]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University Press, 2002: 240-248.
[19] 梁文跃, 李远兴, 凡利娟, 等. 基于LED扩展光源环形均匀光斑的自由曲面透镜设计[J]. 五邑大学学报(自然科学版), 2018, 32(3): 12-17.
Liang W Y, Li Y X, Fan L J, et al. Design of freeform surface lens based on extended LED light source for ring uniform illumination distribution[J]. Journal of Wuyi University (Natural Science Edition), 2018, 32(3): 12-17.
[20] Tsallis C, Stariolo D A. Generalized simulated annealing[J]. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, 1996, 233(1/2): 395-406.
[22] DuK L, SwamyM N S. Bee metaheuristics[M]//Search and optimization by metaheuristics. Cham: Springer, 2016: 201-216.
[23] 彭浩文, 苏拾, 张国玉, 等. 太阳模拟器用变曲率光学积分器研究与设计[J]. 光学学报, 2022, 42(7): 0708001.
[24] 苏拾, 孟凡琳, 张国玉, 等. 氙灯光源太阳模拟器辐照衰减器设计方法[J]. 光学学报, 2021, 41(2): 0208001.
[25] 段文举, 朴明旭, 全向前, 等. 适于扩展光源的紧凑型双自由曲面匀光透镜设计[J]. 光学学报, 2022, 42(15): 1522001.
[26] Saunders I J, Ploeg L, Dorrepaal M, et al. Fabrication and metrology of freeform aluminum mirrors for the SCUBA-2 instrument[J]. Proceedings of SPIE, 2005, 5869: 14-25.
[27] 朱日宏, 孙越, 沈华. 光学自由曲面面形检测方法进展与展望[J]. 光学学报, 2021, 41(1): 0112001.
[28] 李荣彬, 张志辉, 杜雪, 等. 自由曲面光学的超精密加工技术及其应用[J]. 红外与激光工程, 2010, 39(1): 110-115.
Li R B, Zhang Z H, Du X, et al. Ultra-precision machining technology of freeform optics and its applications[J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 2010, 39(1): 110-115.
刘石, 邹国星, 张国玉, 王刚, 张健, 段宗涛, 牛政杰, 任太阳. 太阳模拟器用自由曲面聚光镜设计[J]. 光学学报, 2023, 43(6): 0622001. Shi Liu, Guoxing Zou, Guoyu Zhang, Gang Wang, Jian Zhang, Zongtao Duan, Zhengjie Niu, Taiyang Ren. Design of Free-Form Surface Condenser for Solar Simulator[J]. Acta Optica Sinica, 2023, 43(6): 0622001.